• Search

Court Rules Against NYPD Officer Fired Over Eric Garner’s Death

New York, NY – A state appellate court on Thursday ruled that former NYPD Officer Daniel Pantaleo, who was fired in connection with the death of Eric Garner, should not get his job back.

“We do not find the penalty ‘so disproportionate to the offense, in light of all the circumstances, as to be shocking to one’s sense of fairness,’” the state appellate panel wrote in its decision on March 25, according to the New York Daily News.

“Conduct far less serious than petitioner’s has been found by the Court of Appeals to have a ‘destructive impact… on the confidence which it is so important for the public to have in its police officers,’” the panel wrote.

The panel also said “substantial evidence supports respondents’ conclusion that [Pantaleo] recklessly caused injury to Eric Garner by maintaining a prohibited chokehold for 9 to 10 seconds after exigent circumstances were no longer present, thereby disregarding the risk of injury,” the New York Post reported.

Pantaleo’s attorney, Stuart London, said they were still considering their options, the New York Daily News reported.

“Obviously, my client is disappointed in the judges’ reasoning as well as the decision,” London said. “We’re examining our options on whether to move forward with the Court of Appeals.”

The former NYPD officer filed the wrongful termination lawsuit against the city on Oct. 23, 2019 seeking to get his job back.

The wrongful termination lawsuit called Pantaleo’s firing “arbitrary and capricious,” FOX News reported.

NYPD Police Commissioner James O’Neill had announced the termination of Officer Pantaleo in connection with the death of Eric Garner publicly at a press conference on Aug. 19, 2019.

“The unintended consequence of Mr. Garner’s death must have a consequence of its own,” Commissioner O’Neill told reporters at the time.

He disputed rumors that City Hall and New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio had ordered him to fire the controversial police officer, and said his 34 years as an NYPD police officer had made it a difficult decision.

“If I was still a cop, I’d probably be mad at me. ‘You’re not looking out for us.’ But I am,” Commissioner O’Neill said.

He said that he had considered a separation option for Officer Pantaleo that would have let him keep his pension, but ultimately, decided to do a straightforward termination.

Officer Daniel Pantaleo had been suspended since Aug. 2, 2019 after an NYPD trial judge said he was guilty of using a chokehold on Eric Garner and should be fired.

NYPD Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado issued a non-binding verdict that said Officer Pantaleo was not guilty of aggravated assault or obstructing breathing, but that he had violated department policy regarding the use of chokeholds, WABC reported.

In her decision, Maldonado said she found Officer Pantaleo’s denial of having used a chokehold on Garner “implausible and self-serving,” The New York Times reported.

She claimed the video and the autopsy showed “overwhelming evidence” Officer Pantaleo had used a chokehold despite being trained not to. However, the autopsy actually showed no damage to Garner’s neck.

Deputy Commissioner Maldonado’s recommendation was forwarded to Commissioner O’Neill, who held the power to make the ultimate determination about the fate of the officer’s employment.

Officer Pantaleo was on desk duty for five years after the incident with Garner in July of 2014 until he was suspended more than five years later.

Garner was arrested by NYPD officers on July 17, 2014, after police stopped him for selling individual, untaxed loose cigarettes on a city sidewalk.

He resisted arrest and fought with officers who struggled to take the 350-pound man into custody.

In the process of subduing Garner, video taken by witnesses showed that Officer Pantaleo had his arm around Garner’s neck and pressed his face against the sidewalk.

Garner repeatedly told officers “I can’t breathe,” a phrase that became a rallying cry for Black Lives Matter in the months that followed.

Officer Pantaleo later said he tried to use a “seatbelt maneuver” on Garner, and did not mean to put the much larger man into a choke hold.

Garner lost consciousness on the sidewalk, and died in the hospital an hour later from a medical emergency.

The autopsy report showed no damage to any area of his neck, and it was determined that he died of a medical emergency induced by officers who were arresting him. The medical examiner declared it was a homicide.

A New York Grand Jury declined to indict on any criminal charges.

The federal inquiry has dragged on for years and split the Justice Department in half between those who want to go after the officer and those who thought the officer did nothing wrong, according to The New York Times.

Pantaleo ultimately faced no charges in connection with Garner’s death.

Written by
Sandy Malone

Managing Editor - Twitter/@SandyMalone_ - Prior to joining The Police Tribune, Sandy wrote the Politics.Net column for the Wall Street Journal and was managing editor of Campaigns & Elections magazine. More recently, she was an internationally-syndicated columnist for Conde Nast (BRIDES), The Huffington Post, and Monsters and Critics. Sandy is married to a retired police captain and former SWAT commander.

View all articles
Written by Sandy Malone


Sign up to our daily newsletter so you don't miss out on the latest events surrounding law enforcement!

Follow Me

Follow us on social media and be sure to mark us as "See First."